Overlooked interconversion between tetracyclines and their 4-epimers in soil and effects on soil resistome and bacterial community

Summary

With the widespread use of tetracycline antibiotics (TCs) and the application of manure fertilizer in farmland, TCs and their metabolites especially 4-epimers have been heavily detected in agricultural soil. However, existing studies have focused on the residual and environmental behavior of maternal TCs, and few studies have looked at the ecotoxicity of their 4-epimers in soil. In this study, the degradation and interconversion of tetracycline (TC), oxytetracycline (OTC) and their 4-epimers (4-epitetracycline, ETC; 4-epioxytetracycline, OTC) were revealed. Their effects on antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), mobile genetic elements (MGEs) and bacterial community in soil were also investigated in comparison. The results showed that the 4-epimers could be substantially transformed to their parents and degraded as a whole. The degradation rates of four selected pollutants are followed: TC > OTC > ETC > EOTC. This indicated that when TCs entered the soil, part of TCs transformed into slower-degraded 4-epimers, and these 4-epimers could also be converted back to their antibiotic parents, causing the long-term residue of TCs in soil. When added to the soil alone, TC and OTC significantly promoted the proliferation of most ARGs and MGEs, among them, trb-C, IS1247 and IS1111 were the top three genes in abundance. ETC and EOTC had little effect at the beginning. However, as the 4-epimers continuously converted into their parents after one month of cultivation, ETC and EOTC treatments showed similar promoting effect on ARGs and MGEs, indicating that the effect of ETC and EOTC on soil resistome was lagged and mainly caused by their transformed parents. Nocardioides, unclassified_Rhizobiaceae, norank_Sericytochromatia, Microlunatus, Solirubrobacter and norank_67-14 were the most frequent hosts of ARGs, Most of which belong to the phylum Actinobacteria. Due to their large transformation to TCs, slow degradation rate and potential effects on soil microbes and ARGs, the harm of TCs’ 4-epimers on soil ecosystem cannot be ignored.